Creek Stone Farms Reviews
Creek Stone Farms has an overall rating of 4.5 based on 26 reviews. Customer feedback on Creek Stone Farms is mixed: Creek Stone Farms reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality meat, excellent customer service, fast shipping, great packaging, which strongly appeal to food enthusiasts, health-conscious consumers, gourmet cooks, gift buyers. However, Creek Stone Farms is often criticized for its higher price point, limited product variety, occasional shipping issues, website navigation challenges.
26 reviews
5 Stars
15
4 Stars
6
3 Stars
3
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate Creek Stone Farms?
All Creek Stone Farms Reviews (26)
JoelHall
May 20, 2026
"pretty Good steaks overall"
Picked up a couple steaks from Creekstone Farms and they turned out really nice. Got a good sear in my cast iron and they stayed juicy after resting, which i always appreciate. The flavor was solid too, didn’t need much seasoning at all. One of the steaks was a little uneven in thickness so I had to keep an eye on it while it cooked, but it wasn’t a huge deal. giving it 4 stars because it was definitely good, just not totally perfect
0
Reply
Georgia_chapman87
May 16, 2026
"I’m usually skeptical of all…"
I’m usually skeptical of all the polished company talk about “premium quality” and whatever, but this was actually solid. Prices felt fair for what I got, not the cheapest option out there, but definitely better than the stuff I can find locally. I’ll probably order again next time there’s a sale.
0
Reply
santoshawkins2454
April 18, 2026
"Decent, but I expected fresher"
I was really excited to try this!! The meat arrived cold, which was good, but it didn’t seem quite as fresh as I was hoping. One pack had a slightly off smell when I opened it, so I made sure to use it right away. Once cooked, the taste was fine, just nothing amazing. For the price, I expected it to feel a bit fresher.
0
Reply
felixking3215
April 17, 2026
"Heads Up: Checkout Was Smooth"
Just a heads up for anyone worried about the checkout process, I didn’t run into any issues at all. Everything went through smoothly and was straightforward.
0
Reply
SLIVA
April 16, 2026
"They Made It Right"
In the end, they totally took care of it. I had a small issue with my delivery, so I emailed them not expecting much. But they replied really quickly and fixed everything without making it a hassle. I always appreciate when a company just handles things the right way...
0
Reply
Crystal-tejada
April 05, 2026
"Seems mostly legit, but the vibe was off"
It seems mostly legit overall, but i didn’t love how I was spoken to. The experience itself was fine, but there were moments where I felt like I was being talked down to instead of just helped like a normal customer
0
Reply
louis.Jenkins
April 03, 2026
"Quick and Friendly Help"
I had a question about my order and customer service got back to me really quickly. They helped sort it out without making me jump through hoops, which I appreciated. The whole thing felt easy and friendly, not stressful at all. I’d definitely order again.
0
Reply
MILLER
March 10, 2026
"Showed up fast"
I didn’t really have much to go off of, but the shipping was super quick. It showed up without any issues, so no complaints there.
0
Reply
CarolynLauer_27
March 06, 2026
"really nice quality"
the quality feels super premium. the meat cooked up perfectly and tasted great.
0
Reply
hello_april188
February 21, 2026
"Easy Shopping and Smooth Checkout"
I had a easy time using creekstonefarms.com. I found what I was looking for without any hassle, the menu was straightforward, and the pages loaded quickly for me. Checkout was simple too, which I always appreciate. I also liked that the product details were clear and easy to read. Overall, I’d say it was a smooth shopping experience and I’d feel comfortable ordering from the site again...
0
Reply
GAFFORD
February 18, 2026
"Everything showed up exactly as I…"
Everything showed up exactly as I ordered it. I’m always a little picky about getting the right items, so I was happy there were no surprises...
0
Reply
hello_wayne545
February 16, 2026
"Easy to Order and Usually In Stock"
I really appreciate that most of the cuts I’m looking for are actually in stock when I check. It makes ordering so much easier, and I don’t have to keep coming back over and over hoping something finally shows up. Definitely a smoother experience
0
Reply
KathyMunger
February 10, 2026
"The steaks have shown up evenly cut…"
The steaks have shown up evenly cut every time, which I definitely appreciate. It makes cooking them a lot easier and there’s no hassle with weird sizes. That said, it’s not exactly a standout experience beyond the consistency, but for something simple and reliable, it gets the job done.
0
Reply
hello_john381
February 03, 2026
"Arrived Frozen and Gave Me Some Peace of Mind"
My order showed up right on time, my biggest concern was whether the meat would still be frozen. It was frozen solid, which made me feel like the whole process had been handled properly. There was a little frost inside the box, but no leaks or mess, so that wasn’t a big deal. I’m giving 4 stars only because one corner of the packaging looked a bit beat up, but the food itself seemed totally fine. Overall, it reminded me that good shipping really matters with frozen food, and I’d feel comfortable ordering again
0
Reply
john_Gillen96
January 31, 2026
"I ordered from Creekstone Farms and…"
I ordered from Creekstone Farms and, i was kind of bracing myself to be disappointed because that seems to be how it goes whenever I try something new. But the flavor was actually really great. The steaks had that rich beefy taste I was hoping for and didn’t need much more than salt and pepper. They cooked up nicely, and even my family noticed the difference, which doesn’t always happen. I’ll probably order again, assuming my luck holds up
0
Reply
John-crawford
January 30, 2026
"Heads up: Creekstone steaks are solid, but don’t expect every cut to be perfect"
Just a quick warning for anyone thinking about ordering from creekstonefarms: I ordered a couple of steaks and overall they were really good. The marbling on most of them looked great, they cooked up tender, and the flavor was solid without needing much seasoning. That said, one steak had a little less fat than I was expecting, so it wasn’t totally perfect across the board. Still, compared to what I usually find locally, these were better most of the time. I’d probably order again, but just know there may be a little variation between cuts
0
Reply
william1997
January 29, 2026
"Great Meat, But the Wait Was Frustrating"
I ordered some steaks and ground beef, the quality was really good. Everything tasted fresh and had way more flavor than what I usually get from my local grocery store. The only downside was the waiting, I was getting frustrated by the time it finally arrived. Still, once I cooked it, I was happy with the order.
0
Reply
frances.Walls
January 10, 2026
"Tender and Good"
It was tender, which I always appreciate, and overall good. I kind of found myself thinking about how nice it is when something simple just turns out right, you know? Nothing too over-the-top, just a solid meal that did the job.
0
Reply
CUTCHALL
December 30, 2025
"My order arrived still cold and packed…"
My order arrived still cold and packed so well. The box felt sturdy, there were no leaks or mess, and everything inside looked like it had been really well protected. the packaging was better than I expected. It made me feel like they actually cared about getting my order to me in good shape, and that means a lot. I’d definitely order again
0
Reply
jean1985
December 16, 2025
"Really Happy With My Order"
I was excited they had the specialty cuts I can’t find anywhere local. checkout was super easy too, so that was a nice bonus. Really happy with the whole order and would definitely buy again.
0
Reply
Have a question about Creek Stone Farms?
Log in to ask your Creek Stone Farms question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
